Every board-level executive understands how demanding the role can be. For many, the job requires a significant amount of time, effort, and a substantial personal investment to achieve the best results. When bonus season arrives, receiving an unfair bonus can be deeply frustrating and demoralising.

The first question that may come to mind is, "Can I sue my employer for not paying my bonus?" However, it's essential to examine the finer details of bonuses, the laws regarding discretionary bonuses, and how you can address an ‘unfair’ decision effectively.

Contact us

How Bonuses Work

Bonuses are additional employee payments, often at the end of a specific period, such as the financial year. They are typically tied to individual or company performance and aim to incentivise people to go above and beyond.

Types of Bonuses

• Performance-Based Bonuses

These are tied to specific performance metrics, such as sales targets, customer satisfaction ratings, or project completion.

• Discretionary Bonuses

These are awarded at the discretion of management and are not tied to specific performance metrics. They often reward overall contributions to the company or exceptional performance.

• Sign-On Bonuses

These are offered to attract top talent and are typically paid upfront or over a period of time.

• Referral Bonuses

These are offered to employees who refer successful job candidates to the company.

Can a Company Deny Employees a Bonus?

The contractual agreement between the employer and the employee often influences whether or not a bonus is awarded.

These specific details should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. If you haven't received your bonus, consider the following factors that a company typically takes into account before granting bonuses:

Individual Performance

Individual contributions include sales figures, project completions, or innovative ideas.   

Company Performance

Overall company performance, such as revenue growth, profitability, or market share.   

Job Role and Level

The employee's seniority and the importance of their role to the company.

Company's Financial Health

The company's financial situation and ability to pay bonuses.   

What is an Unfair Bonus? 

An unfair bonus occurs when an employee’s bonus is withheld, reduced, or miscalculated, often violating their employment contract or bonus plan. Besides miscalculations, there are three primary ways a bonus can be considered 'unfair': breach of contract, retaliation, and discrimination.

1. Breach of Contract

Your employment contract and bonus plan are legally binding and outline the terms of your employment, including bonus eligibility. If specific performance metrics are set, your employer must adhere to them and act fairly and in good faith regarding bonus decisions. If you feel they haven't, you may have grounds to challenge their decision.

2. Discrimination

Discrimination in the workplace is illegal in many countries. In the UK, the law protects employees from discrimination in the workplace with the Equality Act 2010, making it illegal to discriminate against someone based on the following:

• Age
• Disability
• Gender reassignment
• Marriage and civil partnership
• Pregnancy and maternity
• Race
• Religion or beliefs
• Sex
• Sexual orientation

Discrimination in bonus decisions can take various forms. 

Direct discrimination occurs when someone is treated less favourably because of a protected characteristic like gender, race, or age. For example, a woman receiving a lower bonus than a man for the same job exemplifies this.

Indirect discrimination involves seemingly neutral policies that disproportionately disadvantage individuals with specific protected characteristics. An example is a bonus scheme requiring long hours, which can negatively affect working parents, especially women.

3. Retaliation

Retaliation happens when an employer takes negative action against an employee for exercising their legal rights. 

This may involve demotion, termination, or a reduction in pay, including bonuses. If an employer withholds or reduces a bonus as a form of retaliation for reporting misconduct, whistleblowing, or filing a complaint related to discrimination or harassment, it is considered illegal. Such actions can lead to serious consequences for the employer.

What is the Discretionary Bonus Law UK

In the UK, there is no specific law that governs discretionary bonuses. Instead, their legality is determined by employment contracts and general principles of fairness and reasonableness.

If a bonus is explicitly stated in an employment contract, it becomes a contractual entitlement. This means that the employer is obligated to pay the bonus if the specified conditions are met.

On the other hand, discretionary bonuses are not guaranteed and are awarded at the employer's discretion. While employers have the freedom to decide whether to grant a discretionary bonus, they must do so in a reasonable and fair manner.

Can I Sue My Employer for Not Paying My Bonus?

Bonuses are a crucial aspect of nearly every workplace culture and are vital for creating an environment that motivates and values employees.

Therefore, it’s essential that you receive any financial compensation you are entitled to. If you're wondering, “Can I sue my employer for not paying my bonus?”, it's important to understand your rights regarding whether a company can withdraw a bonus or if you've received an unfair bonus.

3 Steps to Take When Facing an Unfair Bonus

1. Review Your Employment Contract and Bonus Plan

The first step in challenging an unfair bonus is to review your employment contract and bonus plan. These documents outline the terms and conditions of your employment, including your bonus eligibility, across four key clauses. 

Bonus Eligibility Criteria

Look for specific criteria that must be met to qualify for a bonus, such as performance targets, sales goals, or company performance metrics.

Bonus Calculation Methods

Understand the formula or methodology for calculating your bonus, including any relevant factors or adjustments.

Payment Schedule

Determine the timing of bonus payments, whether they are paid annually, quarterly, or at another specified time.

Dispute Resolution Procedures

If your contract includes a dispute resolution procedure, familiarise yourself with the steps involved.

You must carefully review your contract and bonus plan to identify any potential breaches or unfair practices.

2. Document Everything

To build a strong case, keep detailed records of all communications about your bonus. Save emails, meeting notes, and performance reviews that mention bonus eligibility or targets. Document any interactions with HR or management, including verbal and written discussions about concerns or complaints. Maintaining this comprehensive record will be invaluable for any legal proceedings.

3. Communicate with Your Employer

If your employer has a formal grievance procedure, follow it by submitting a written grievance that outlines your concerns and requests an investigation.

If no such procedure exists, or you prefer a direct approach, speak with your HR department or manager. Communicate your concerns clearly and refer to specific terms in your contract or bonus plan.

Rely on the Experts at Cavendish Employment Law

An unfair bonus can be incredibly frustrating and demoralising, often leading to feelings of betrayal and resentment. This emotional toll can diminish your motivation and sense of worth. 

It's essential not to accept the strain of an unfair bonus. Instead, challenge it to regain fairness and secure your financial stability.

When navigating severance negotiations, protecting your rights is crucial. Always seek legal advice before signing any agreements. 

Cavendish Employment Law specialises in complex, high-value claims, offering expert guidance for executives facing unfair bonuses. Our experienced team understands the unique challenges of senior executives and is dedicated to achieving the best possible outcomes. 

We carefully review every clause to safeguard your rights and employ effective negotiation tactics for additional compensation, including back pay, punitive damages, and statutory uplifts.

Don't Let Unfairness Prevail: Fight for Your Rights

Don't let your hard work and dedication go unrewarded. If you believe your bonus has been unfairly withheld, reduced, or calculated, contact us today for a free consultation.

Cavendish Employment Law’s experienced employment lawyers are here to help you:

• Understand Your Rights: We will explain your legal rights and options.
• Build a Strong Case: We will help you gather evidence to support your claim.
• Negotiate a Fair Settlement: We will work to negotiate a fair settlement with your employer.

Don't let an unfair bonus set the standard. Take action and we will help you to obtain what you deserve.

Contact us