Make an Online Payment

Tribunal rules employee referred to as 'baby farmer' was unfairly dismissed

An employee at logistics firm Pall-Ex who was called a “baby farmer” by her finance director following her return to work from maternity leave was unfairly dismissed, a Leister employment tribunal found.

Miss L Hayman faced direct sex discrimination and harassment based on protected characteristics on specific occasions in her work. The tribunal heard how Ms Hayman was shouted at and dealt with “bullying behaviour” from her line manager, Mr Tancock, with one incident leaving Ms Hayman in tears in the work toilets.

However, a number of separate sexual discrimination claims by Ms Hayman were dismissed by the tribunal because they were made out of time, dating back to 2011.

In November 2013, the claimant was asked for an update on the finances relating to a specific client when she was allegedly told by her finance director, David Gannon that “nothing has happened since you’ve been busy being a baby farmer.”

The judges concluded the “baby farmer” comment constituted unfavourable treatment, and that the bullying behaviour Ms Hayman had faced were a breach of implied terms of trust and confidence in the claimant’s contract.

On her return to work, Ms Hayman explained to the tribunal that she began noticing her manager making references to her parental duties, sending an email in March 2017 saying: “Can you tell me when you get a moment in between nappy changing?”

Alongside a number of other incidents - including Tancock shouting at Ms Hayman, being harassed with phone calls while sick, and the head of sales and Tancock making jokes at the expense of Ms Hayman - the judges ruled the behaviour “clearly constitutes conduct which is calculated or likely to damage or destroy trust and confidence”.

Contact our Employment Lawyers, London

If you have been unfairly dismissed or endured discrimination at your place of work, get in touch with one of our qualified employment lawyers for specialist legal advice and representation. Contact us today via the online enquiry form

Head Office – Change of Address
New mothers to get extended 'protected period' whe


Cavendish Award Logo

Get in touch

Whether you are an employee, executive, director, senior employer or businessowner we promise swift, confidential and expert advice.
Out of Hours & Weekend Advice Available
Please let us know your name.
Please let us know your email address.
Please enter a valid telephone number
Please let us know your message.
Invalid captcha

What our clients say

View all our testimonials
Contact us today for expert advice on employment law issues.
Call us on 020 7167 4800